This is our reading of The Economist's Business piece of 2026-09-16, «Nannying for the ultra-rich is increasingly demanding and lucrative», which ran in print as «Spoonfuls of sugar». Read the original →
On the surface this is a piece about a spectacle. We are not here for the spectacle.
We are here for something else. This is a controlled experiment. In this market money is not a constraint at all. Anything can be bought: more hours, higher qualifications, more languages, more expensive institutions.
So when a family can buy anything, where does the money actually go?
The answer sits in the middle of the piece, in a single line, and it is very nearly free.
First, the shape of the job.
She works at least twelve hours a day, seven days a week, and then has a full week off. She might earn around $200,000 a year, which at an hourly rate is on a par with a private-equity associate.
High pay for long hours on a rota belongs, historically, to oil platforms, mines and container ships. It now also belongs to another exacting field: caring for the children of the super-rich.
A decade ago such posts were rare. Anita Rogers, who founded British American Household Staffing in 2012 and now says she has 7,000 clients, remembers the old response: "Oh, I’m not paying that." Now it is quite the opposite.
Clients want nannies who have not only trained at the best academies (Norland University of Early Childhood, a British school more than a century old) but who also speak several languages, hold degrees from elite universities, will travel constantly and put in very long days. And they are willing to pay.
But the content of the work has not changed.
This is the most important line in the piece and the easiest for the glamour to bury: nannying for the children of the very rich is the same as for those of the merely affluent, bottle-feeding, preparing meals, trips to the playground.
What differs is the surroundings. She is often one of a dozen staff rather than the sole employee. "They want nannies that have experience on yachts and jets," Rogers says. "It’s just a given."
Now the structural change. This is the one genuinely important finding in the whole article.
Before the pandemic, the richest clients, who could afford as many hours of child care as they could possibly want, would often cobble arrangements together: one nanny Monday to Friday, another for the weekend, a babysitter for a night out. If the parents had to work late, they would hope the weekday nanny could cover the extra hours at the last minute. To take someone on a trip, she would need to make arrangements for her own family and be paid for longer hours and perhaps a travel fee, or else they would hire a different nanny, whom their children did not know.
Now, two nannies, one on and the other off, can cover every daytime hour of every day of the year.
The reason the piece gives is one line: "there is much less disruption."
Stop here for a moment.
These are the wealthiest families in the world, facing a problem they can throw an unlimited amount of money at. What they ended up buying was not more hours, not higher qualifications, not a more expensive institution.
What they bought was this: the same adult, known to the child, present without interruption.
Sort what the money buys. Four things.
One: continuity. This is the one that matters.
An adult the child recognises, uninterrupted. Notice how weak the relationship is between that and money, and how strong the relationship is between that and a calendar. Who, in which slot, and whether it is the same person each time, none of those decisions costs $200,000.
Two: coordination cost driven to zero.
The parents no longer make a Friday-evening phone call begging for cover, or improvise a plan the night before a trip. What they bought is certainty, not hours. This one does genuinely cost money.
Three: credential inflation.
Elite academies, several languages, degrees from top universities, for a job whose actual content, by the article’s own account, is bottle-feeding and the playground.
This is the same mechanism as the other piece we published this week. When the number of university seats is fixed and every family bids more at once, the bar rises and the seats do not (positional good, the full argument is here). Here, the thing being bid up is the person holding your child.
Why does this happen? Because the buyer has no way to tell real quality apart. No parent can determine, in an interview, who will be more patient at three in the morning. So they buy the observable proxy instead: the degree, the languages, the name of the institution. The credential is doing exactly the job it does in admissions. It is a signal, not the content.
Four: the absurd part.
One nanny recalls an ultra-rich family who required her to iron their son’s underwear every day. Another parent was furious that she did not immediately fetch a ladder to replace a light bulb in the playroom ceiling, while caring for their small children. The ceiling was 17 feet high.
Analysis: this is the boundary of purchased care. A service relationship can be bought, and it can also be degraded at will. A relationship cannot be ordered. The gap between those two things is what the article is really about.
Where the cost lands.
There is one passage in the reporting that deserves to be remembered over everything else in it:
> "If I stay in this for ever, I can’t have kids. If I get out of this, where is my income?" , Lauren Lomascolo, who has nannied for wealthy clients for a decade
She also said this: "Before I really dove into child care, if you would have asked me my entire life from the start of four years old, what do you want to be when you grow up? I would have said a stay-at-home mom."
Analysis: this is opportunity cost with a face on it. Someone who wanted to be a mother from the age of four found, a decade in, that the job of raising other people’s children had made her own children impossible. The piece we published this week on what that same arithmetic looks like across a whole generation is here.
And this is not a problem with her choices. It is a problem with the structure of the post: a twelve-hour, seven-day rota is a shift system designed for oil rigs, mines and cargo ships. An arrangement that solves one family’s childcare can make another person’s family impossible.
So what does a family on an ordinary budget take from this?
Take the first thing. Continuity. And it is mostly scheduling, not spending.
Three specifics:
One. The same adult, in the same slot. The school run, Saturday morning, the twenty minutes before sleep. Let the same person appear in the same square. That is what a child’s body records, not whichever single interaction was the most heartfelt. (This is the same claim, differently worded, as Juli Fraga’s method and Alan Macfarlane’s order, both of which we have written about.)
Two. Reduce the number of handovers. Every extra adult the child does not know, brought in to cover a slot, is an interruption however good that adult is. Better to run one activity fewer and keep the arrangement unbroken. That is precisely what the richest families spent $200,000 on, and you can buy most of it with a calendar.
Three. Stop paying for observable proxies. The fourth activity, the programme joined for one line on a form. The richest families buy those because they have no way of telling real quality apart.
You can tell. Because you are in the room. That is your single advantage over $200,000, and it is a large one.
Honesty about the material.
Most of the structural claims in this reporting come from Anita Rogers, who founded and runs an agency that sells this service. There is no independent data series on pay or market size. So wherever the above describes how the market has changed, treat it as her account rather than as established fact.
There is also a passage about reality television and celebrity, Hulu’s «Million Dollar Nannies», aired in June, set in Ibiza, six women and two men competing for posts with rich households. We are not passing that part on. It is not what this is about. The source’s own closing line is sharp, though: the fantasy that show offers is not being one of the rich, but being employed by them.
One sentence to tie the three together.
The Economist’s three pieces this week are three views of one machine. Intensive parenting raises the cost of a child (here). That higher cost makes a third child stop adding up (here). And at the very top, care itself becomes a profession that gets bid up (this one).
All three point at the same sentence: the part that actually stays in a child was never the part being bid for.
Questions to sit with
1. In your child’s past week, which slot was the same adult at the same time? If you cannot name one, that is the single thing this piece suggests you do, and it costs nothing.
2. In your current arrangement, how many handovers happen in a week, meaning how many different adults and how many different sets of rules does the child meet? Can that number come down by one?
3. The richest families buy degrees and languages because they cannot tell real quality apart. Of the things you are paying for on your child’s behalf, how many are things whose quality you also cannot judge, bought because they are visible?
from The Economist
Reader discussion
You have read it. What do you make of it?
Loading…